California’s Unemployment Insurance (UI) system, supporting over 1.6 million people, is facing a major crisis that threatens its sustainability and effectiveness. Originally designed to provide temporary wage replacement for jobless workers, the system is now drowning in billions of dollars in debt. Outdated policies and financial instability are pushing it toward a breaking point, raising serious concerns about whether it can withstand the next economic downturn.
Right now, California owes the federal government approximately $20 billion in unemployment insurance (UI) debt. This massive debt accumulated during the COVID-19 pandemic when the state had to borrow money to cover the overwhelming number of unemployment claims.
To put that in perspective, California now has to pay over $1 billion in interest on this debt every year, which is more than what the state spends on child welfare programs. The financial trouble of the unemployment insurance (UI) system is not entirely pandemic-induced. Even before COVID-19, the system had been long plagued, leading to recurring insolvency.
According to Department of Labor data analyzed by the Century Foundation, despite being solvent in 2018 and 2019, the fund remained below the recommended standard of having enough reserves to cover a year’s worth of benefits. The last time the fund met this standard was in 1990—more than 30 years ago.
One of the biggest issues is how much employers contribute into the system. Right now, California businesses only pay unemployment taxes on the first $7,000 of each employee’s annual wages—a threshold that has remained unchanged since 1983.
In stark contrast, many other states have significantly higher taxable wage bases. For example, Washington state’s taxable wage base is $72,800 for 2025. Because California’s tax base is so low, the state doesn’t collect enough money to keep the unemployment insurance (UI) system financially stable.
This means every time there’s an economic crisis—whether it’s a recession or a pandemic—the system runs out of money and has to borrow from the federal government.
Liz Ortega, an assemblywoman from the Labor and Employment committee, has been vocal about the need for reform. She noted that California’s maximum weekly UI benefit of $450 has remained stagnant for two decades, even though wages and the cost of living have skyrocketed.
Ortega emphasized the urgency of addressing these systemic issues, stating, “Since 2004, no governor and no Legislature has done anything about [unemployment insurance].” Some experts also voiced similar sentiments, adding that the limited nature of California’s benefits and outdated taxable wage base makes it a laggard nationally.
The shortcomings of the Unemployment Insurance (UI) system have direct consequences for California’s workforce. The biggest problem is that the system is not always reliable when they need it most.
During the pandemic, around 5 million unemployed Californians faced delays in receiving benefits—some even waited months to get their very first payment. Many people who should have qualified for unemployment never received the help they needed. At the same time, the system was hit with massive fraud, leading to billions in losses.
And because the state now owes billions to the federal government, California businesses will face higher taxes to help pay off the debt. This could make it harder for businesses to hire new workers, potentially leading to fewer job opportunities in the future.
California’s Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) has stated that the Unemployment Insurance (UI) system is “broken” and needs serious reforms.
Some possible solutions include:
Despite these recommendations, substantial reforms have yet to materialize. The political sensitivity surrounding tax increases poses a significant hurdle, leaving the system vulnerable to future crises.
California’s Unemployment Insurance (UI) system needs to find a way to make its system more stable, fair, and efficient for both workers and businesses. If it does not, the state could end up in an even bigger financial pitfall the next time the economy takes a hit.
For now, the $20 billion debt remains a ticking time bomb, and unless major reforms happen soon, California could be in for another unemployment crisis when it can least afford it.
Share this article:
